The negative costs of our nation’s “war on drugs” reach into so many aspects our country that they are almost impossible to count. This isn’t just the direct cost of incarceration, enforcement, and the loss of tax revenue, there are also the many less obvious costs such as long-term lower wages for those with drug-related criminal records and, as I recently learned, the destruction of our domestic flower industry.
A few decades ago, when Americans bought flowers, they were likely grown in America by a very large domestic flower industry. This domestic industry has basically been wiped out as a casualty in our fight against drugs. From the Smithsonian Magazine’s look at the rise of the Colombian flower industry:
This growth took place in a country ravaged by political violence for most of the 20th century and by the cocaine trade since the 1980s, and it came with significant help from the United States. To limit coca farming and expand job opportunities in Colombia, the U.S. government in 1991 suspended import duties on Colombian flowers. The results were dramatic, though disastrous for U.S. growers. In 1971, the United States produced 1.2 billion blooms of the major flowers (roses, carnations and chrysanthemums) and imported only 100 million. By 2003, the trade balance had reversed; the United States imported two billion major blooms and grew only 200 million.
In their zealous desire to wage a war on drugs, the policymakers in Washington were more than willing to nearly eliminate an entire domestic industry merely on the hope it would reduce the production of one drug in one country. Even knowing the likely result was that production of that drug would simply move to a neighboring nation.
Both the direct and indirect costs that come out of the war on drugs are so numerous we will probably never be able to fully calculate what this policy has truly cost our country.


40 Comments
But hey the big boys are making big profit from this War on Drugs! a few flower growers mean nothing compared to their profits…
There will be no full accounting of what this first “endless war” has cost, in human terms, in financial terms, in terms of what was “lost” or could not happen.
Where have all the flowers gone?
Where has our democracy gone?
Where have reason and the rule of law gone?
No, we will never look back and consider …
Until the moralizing hypocrisy of political expediency, the much-loved “pragmatism” and “hard love” of the political class on the make is no longer tolerated, but seen as the true danger which IT represents.
The War on Drugs launched a thousand political careers and made a lot of money for a few, as well as allowed certain government “agencies” to finance operations the people were never to know of.
Who, really, benefits from these brutal (let us be honest) endless wars, the people, the nation, or just a cynical few?
Thanks, Jon, a bouquet of appeciation to you.
DW
Nahant, yeah, and I’ll go ya one further.
By eliminating domestic production, and controlling imports from drug producing nations, I bet the damned CIA and others get a cut from the flower import biz, too.
Off the books, of course, so they can ‘reinvest’ that money in black ops, etc., pay off COngress, Judges and more.
‘What, ME paranoid? I KNOW they’re out to get me!”
*G*
Thanks for the read Mr. Walker, and all your work too . . .
I worked in the flower industry back in the 70s(in CA). Even then we were hurt by preferential treatment for Colombian carnations -and Israeli roses altho that wasn’t drug related. Yep, we destroyed the American floriculture industry.
Idiots.
Is that who was looking through your bedroom window the other night???
Half Moon Bay still still has a decent flower growing business but probably no where what they used to grow… Their veggies are great though..
Larue has flowers looking through his windows?
At night, you say?
Must be night-bloomers.
How be ya, Nahant?
DW
Great DW and you??
Dudes! It’s, like, millertime or something. You got me grinning.
Sorry. I’ll go back to just watching you guys. And, enjoying.
I’m thinking of all of the drug rehab that could have been funded with the billions wasted on this.
Not too shabby. Been thinkin’ ’bout flower power, in days of yore, Nahant.
You know, sex, drugs, and rock ‘n rollover Beethoven?
Today’s kindda brought a lot of things around again, if ya know what I mean?
;~DW
Wall flowerin’, huh demi?
Were you not, mere hours ago, talkin’ hot wheels, hot engines, and dirt bikes in the desert?
Must be some of that “prerogative” stuff and such-like, I imagine.
;~DW
At the school dances that’s exactly what I was good at. On the bench. But, as to perogatives, I got loadsa dat. Buckets. I can ever talk flowers if you want.
I do… But it is a great day for the human condition… We are still on the path to civilization… Always a good day when that happens…
Yes and the vibes sparked several very interesting discussions today.
PS – thanks for the Frank, earlier.
My pleasure demi your comment immediately reminded me of that song… sweetie is giving back to back Oboe and Flute lessons this afternoon so I can hide in my room and hang with you guys…
Thass better.
Now, I reckon you live where you got flowers all year round.
But where I live, it is the spring flowers in the woodlands that start the year. First we get Colt’s Foot and by the time the Foxglove are up we got verdantly radiant forests punctuated with slashes of brilliant color, this is after the Red Bud of course and the pastel colors of the leafing-out …
What’s plant and flower-things like out your way?
DW
Being sent to your room nowadays sure is more fun than 50 years ago, huh?
A grand and significant day, today, a gift to the world, to life, and to human beings, Nahant.
DW
we got verdantly radiant forests punctuated with slashes of brilliant color
Astounding.
There’s lots of fruit trees that are blossoming right now. I’ve got some pink jasmine starting to bloom. It’s one of my favorites, but I have to take antihistamines. But, it’s worth it. There’s roses and primroses. There’s flowering cactus and succulents. And, now my broccoli plants have gone to flower.
Doesn’t have the same “impact”.
“Young lady! GO to your room … immediately!”
” … And no computer, no TV, no cell phone, no … none of those music things and … not even that little one … and I’d better not hear the stereo … where are the earphones? “”"!
Oh, you meant being the sendee?
I got a ten-year-old, my youngest, (she’s got my number … old dad has to be pretty PO-ed to do the “Go to your room!” scene … and she knows it …)
;~DW
Specially as my puter and other nice things are here … wink wink..
Stepping away. BBL
Good luck Dw I am glad those days are over with my girls… Sheesh there were days when I just wanted to ship them off to Siberia till they turned 18!! But hey I preserved and now they are sweeties… Knew I had them when they started telling me “Dad I know why you said no all those times now” .. Yes they have their own little ones.. Tis fun to watch.. at a distance that is..
The few patches of virgin woodlots that remain are truly astonding, here in the temperate rainforests of Penn’s Woods, the White Pine and Hemlock stems reach six to eight feet in diameter at breast height and soar one hundred fifty and more into the heavens.
Such places are sanctuaries of spiritual recreation and cannot fail to impress even the most jaded.
DW
Come see the Redwood Dw they are just amazing.. Of course I am also inspired by the Ocean.. When I migrated West I just had to be near the Ocean.. It’s changing Moods and Beauty are just so calming to the soul..
The Redwoods, Nahant, are another thing!
And the Oceans, you describe so very well, are an elemental reminder of the force and majesty of nature.
What a treasure is this Earth, this paradise we so fortuitously inhabit.
Who could fail to love it?
Ah, Nahant, the joy and exultant exuberance of life!
Of sentiency, of consciousness!
We are such lucky beings.
DW
Isn’t it time for U.S. horticulturalists to organize? Oh, that’s right U.S. workers are discouraged from organizing. Let the magic of the market work it’s wonders.
Very true DW, having grown up next to the Atlantic and living near the Pacific gives you a sense of the rhythm of life, with all it’s ebbs and flows… Truly amazing to comprehend so much about our selves in the greater Universe as we have been able to see and perceive so far.. Life is a wonder!! Much more than can be expressed in words alone.. There is much more to life than just what we can see… The American Indians had it right ” We are all connected to Nature”..
This is not true. Colombia made a decision during the government of Carlos Lleras Restrepo (1966-1970) to develop new export commodities to lessen its dependence on coffee which then account for almost 90% of export dollars. One of the industries that the Colombian govt chose to then develop was the flower industry.
Colombia’s cut flower industry is now the second largest in the world after Holland. Furthermore the US cut flower industry, largely centered in California, face its own internal issues that led to its decline. Namely it was priced out of land which was developed for ever-expanding tract housing.
To conflate the war on drugs with the growth of the Colombian flower industry is an error. Colombia’s cut flower industry was already the world’s second largest by 1991 when the US preferential tariffs were extended.
Mind you, the war on drugs is a 40 year failure but the Colombia flower industry is 45 year success story. Lastly this post reeks of US centrism, Mr. Walker is suggesting that without the US tariffs the Colombian flower industry would not be where it is today. Perhaps not to the extent that it is since the US is Colombia’s largest market but even without the US, Colombia would still be the world’s number two producer and the success of the industry is almost entirely due to the Colombian state economic planning. The Colombian flower industry is one of these examples of the state taking an active role in economic development. Examples abound in East Asia but in Latin American, another example is Chile’s salmon industry, now the world’s second largest after Norway.
You seem to be very well-informed, factanonverba.
If America is Columbia’s largest market, as you say, and you imply that this had and has no affect upon American flower growers, then you must be suggesting either that American flower growers are doing better than Jon does, or, that if American flower-growers are not doing well, then their “problems” have nothing to do with “competition”, at least from Columbian growers. Would that be correct?
If so, then are American growers doing okay, or are they not?
If they are not, have you any ideas as to why that might be?
DW
The war on drugs does no good and does much harm. Obama is opposed to ending it. Is he stupid or is he an ass hole?
both?
If you’re still here, or come back,…wink wink back attcha.
“Where has our democracy gone”?
How about, “Where has our Constitutional Republic gone?
Has anyone checked out the United States entry on the corrupted Wikipedia? According to them, we are now a “Federal presidential constitutional republic.”
The US cut flower industry is effectively dead. But its demise is not directly tied to the 1991 Andean Trade Act that granted US tariff preferences to all sorts of Andean agricultural products. Peru, for example, is the largest US source of asparagus.
There is another factor that comes into play which Mr. Walker averts. The Reagan Administration and the Thatcher government had destroyed the world coffee cartel based in London which fixed prices for producers while guaranteeing supplies to consuming nations. That had an averse effect on Colombia which saw coffee prices plummet. Reagan did this in his misguided devotion to free markets but a consequence was a surge in cocaine traffic. In part, the 1991 Andean Trade Act was passed to undo the damage that the neoliberal agenda had done to what was a very good arrangement for global coffee consumers and producers.
To your question, the US flower industry has been in decline for 30 years but that’s not just solely due to the rise of Colombia, Guatemala and Ecuador as producers. There are internal reasons for its decline unrelated to the war on drugs.
Flowers are a very labour intensive industry and only the Dutch have been able to maintain their industry among OECD nations even though their market share has been cut in half over the past 30 years. The world flower industry is essentially a trifurcated one: Holland, Spain, Israel, Kenya are the main European suppliers; Colombia, Ecuador and Guatemala are the main producers in the West Hemisphere while Australia, Indonesia and Vietnam are the main producers in the Asia-Pacific region. Still, Holland and Colombia control over 60% of world trade.
Mind you, the war on drugs is forty year failure. There is no escaping that sad fact.
Thank you, factanonverba, for your response.
I note your Brit spelling of “labour” and wonder, if I am not too inquisitive, where you hail from and what your profession or background might be?
I ask out of simple curiosity, as I appeciate knowing about the lives, perspectives and experiences of those who comment here. That I might have better understanding and greater appreciation.
;~DW
He is certainly stubborn, arrogant, elitist, a liar, willfully blind, and an incredible asshole without, so far as I can see, any redeeming qualities. Because I don’t believe anyone is totally evil or good, I assume that he has some redeeming virtues, for example, his family appears to love him. As a leader, however, he is an absolute disaster.
I couldn’t believe that 7 minute speech he gave about Egypt yesterday. I am speechless considering how a man who so dislikes democracy and the poor in his own country could give such a great sounding speech. Made me want to vomit listening to him.